Reviews of

Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary by Conceptual Categories: A Student’s Guide to Nouns in the Old Testament

In Biblical Hebrew Language, HB/OT, Hebrew Language, J. David PLEINS, Jonathan HOMRIGHAUSEN, Kerry Lee, Zondervan on November 17, 2017 at 6:10 pm

2017.12.24 | J. David Pleins with Jonathan Homrighausen, Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary by Conceptual Categories: A Student’s Guide to Nouns in the Old Testament. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 2017. ISBN: 9780310530749

Review by Kerry Lee

Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary by Conceptual Categories: A Student’s Guide to Nouns in the Old Testament, by J. David Pleins and Jonathan Homrighausen, is a lexical aid for students and teachers of Biblical Hebrew that arranges over 2,000 Hebrew nouns into over 175 conceptual categories, or semantic fields. This book is highly versatile with many uses not only for beginning students but also for intermediate and advanced students as well as for teachers.

The way Biblical Hebrew has traditionally been taught follows a largely deductive, grammar-first-vocabulary-second approach (the majority of beginner grammars all follow more or less the same basic structure, with some minor variations). While this approach might work for university students, it often proves problematic for non-traditional students (working adults and retirees, among whom there are many who desire to learn Biblical Hebrew). In fact, personal experience calls into question whether it really is the best method for any but the most dedicated and academically minded of university students.

For many MDiv students in seminaries, the traditional deductive approach, both to Hebrew and Greek (and represented perfectly in Greek by William Mounce’s Basics of Biblical Greek), just does not work in making the languages accessible and usable for future ministers. The main alternative has been an inductive approach (teaching not through paradigms but by introducing grammar step-by-step through assisted translation of a strategically ordered series of phrases and sentences from the Hebrew Bible). Perhaps the most well known example would be Kittel, Hoffer, and Wright’s Biblical Hebrew. However, personal experience has shown that the lack of almost any deductive grammatical structure (e.g., paradigms) until late in the book left my students with formless data that made memorization more difficult. Moreover, Kittel, Hoffer, and Wright’s grammar has one key feature in common with its more traditional counterparts: an emphasis on grammar over vocabulary. Vocabulary is introduced each chapter based upon what grammatical features had been covered.

The problem with this sort of approach to learning Biblical Hebrew, and a chief problem motivating the construction of Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary by Conceptual Categories, is that individual words in the vocabulary lists from each chapter of a traditional grammar are usually isolated from each other semantically. In other words, a chapter may give the student 15 words to memorize. These 15 words, however, are not all words for animals, or for tools, or for landforms; they will all be III-א verbs or middle weak verbs. Each word typically occupies a unique semantic domain. The reason why this is problematic is that our brains learn things better in conceptual chunks where multiple related items are learned together and understood partly in distinction one from another. In this way, we help our brain to acquire the vocabulary by creating mental spaces and then populating those spaces with mutually defining webs of words. Otherwise, as the authors of this book note in their introduction, “vocabulary building is reduced to rote memorization that all too often becomes an exercise in futility” (p. 16). Not only is vocabulary building in the traditional manner difficult and boring, it often fails to stick in the brains of most students, because it is unnatural.

To address this problem in Hebrew pedagogy, Pleins and Homrighausen have produced a highly versatile tool, intended as a supplement to a traditional grammar, that not only aids students in learning vocabulary but offers advancing students an introduction into the realm of Old Testament lexical studies. The book can be used to quickly and easily find synonyms or related words for a keyword in a text – a function potentially very useful for pastors preparing sermons as well as for seminary students and even scholars (albeit in the very early stages of a new research project). As a teaching tool, the book has wide range of potential uses. The authors have suggested some such uses in the book’s introduction (pp. 19-20).

Biblical Hebrew Vocabulary by Conceptual Categories is arranged simply and sensibly. The book’s conceptual fields are divided into four large categories: (1) The Created Order, (2) The Human Order, (3) The Social Order, and (4) The Constructed Order. Within each of these large categories are between four and eight intermediate categories. Each intermediate category is furthermore subdivided into basic categories wherein the words actually appear. For example, within “The Created Order” the fifth intermediate category is “Animals”, within which one finds in their own respective lists general terms for animals, the names of various kinds of birds, the various words for cattle, the various words for sheep and goats, names for enclosures and troughs, names of tools pertaining to animal husbandry, and so on and so forth in 11 further categories. Within each category, the number of words can vary considerably, from two words to more than two dozen.

Pleins and Homrighausen have made a conscious decision to focus on nouns rather than verbs. This includes substantive participles, but other than that verbs make only the rare appearance when, in the authors’ words, “they seem key to the semantic field as an assistance to the student” (p. 19). The reason for this decision is that, traditionally, the teaching of Biblical Hebrew has been heavy on verbs and light on nouns because of the nature of Hebrew grammar. The unfortunate result is that often when students finish a couple of semesters of Biblical Hebrew they find themselves unable to read hardly any of the Hebrew Bible without constant reference to a dictionary. This is unnatural and discouraging for the early Hebrew student. The intention of the book is that by having students focus on memorizing thousands of nouns in conceptually related lists, those students should find Hebrew more immediately accessible and more rewarding. Moreover, a student who finds Hebrew accessible and rewarding will go on to use Hebrew more actively and accurately in their subsequent studies or ministry.

Each word listing is made up of between three and five parts: the Hebrew word, a list of English glosses (one word translations), an optional citation of a scholarly source for one or more of the glosses, a sample scripture reference where the word occurs, and an optional designation of the word as R (meaning “rare” or occurring fewer than 10 times in the Hebrew Bible) or H (meaning “hapax legomenon”, which is a Greek term that means the word only occurs once within a given body of literature). The scope of this book is the Hebrew Bible. It does not include non-canonical Second Temple period Jewish literature written in Hebrew, Hebrew inscriptions, or Late/Rabbinic Hebrew. The authors chose to deal with the issue of word frequency in this manner because they feel that a student ought not to neglect the learning of certain words simply because they occur infrequently in the Bible. Nevertheless, they acknowledge that it is useful to know at a glance which words are more or less common in a given conceptual category.

This book is not a lexicon, meaning it does not offer an in-depth discussion of the various meanings and nuances of each word. Rather, it is a lexical aid for students. Therefore, it presents only a handful of glosses for each Hebrew word. The authors have made an effort, however, to make sure that those glosses are as reliable as they can be. Rather than simply supplying traditional renderings (such as one finds in the dictionary portion of a Strong’s concordance), the authors have made use of new and up-to-date scholarly resources, including newer lexica and specialist monographs and articles. These resources are listed at the beginning of the book in a list of abbreviations and a bibliography.

The citations of scholarly sources show up as abbreviations or author last names in parentheses after the glosses. At times, an entry will consist of two or more groups of glosses with different citations for each group. For example, for the Hebrew word לְטָאָה (ləṭāʾā(h) – which happens to be a hapax legomenon) the entry shows “lizard; reptile (ELT); lacertid lizard (SDBH); gecko (HALOT)”. What this means, if I am understanding it correctly, is that “lizard” suffices as a basic and generally accepted translation of ləṭāʾā(h), but Oded Borowski’s Every Living Thing: Daily Use of Animals in Ancient Israel chooses to render it “reptile” (which is less specific than “lizard”), the Semantic Dictionary of Biblical Hebrew suggests “lacertid lizard” (which is more specific than “lizard”), and the Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament offers “gecko” (which is more specific than “lizard” but disagrees with SDBH). These unobtrusive abbreviations quickly enable the reader to see a range of possible meanings for a given word, especially where there is some level of disagreement in that range.

The authors have included at the end of the book two short appendices and two indexes. The first appendix is a guide to further reading on the vocabulary of each intermediate category. The second appendix, titled “Cluster Verses for Study”, is a list of biblical passages that can be read for the purpose of studying each conceptual category in a textual context. This appendix will be especially useful for teachers. The first index is an alphabetically arranged list of all the words that appear in the book. The second is a scripture index.

I honestly can think of no way to improve upon this book, at least not definitively. While I think a similar arrangement of Hebrew verbs would be helpful, the book’s self-imposed limitation to nouns is understandable. Designating words as “rare” or as a “hapax legomenon” rather than giving a comprehensive listing of number of occurrences for each word works just fine for the stated purpose of the book. Admittedly, if it had been up to me, I would have chosen numbers of occurrences. Both of these choices, however, were made in part to keep the book simple and focused. The book is intended primarily to be an aid for students of Hebrew, not a reference book for specialists.

I would recommend this book to teachers of Biblical Hebrew as a required textbook for their students. I would also recommend this book for self-motivated grad students and pastors who perhaps need some help in building their vocabulary beyond what they managed to acquire while taking Hebrew courses in seminary or university. While the specialist has resources available to him or her that surpass this book, I, personally, find it to be quite a useful ready reference, particularly as a way of familiarizing myself with the vocabulary of a conceptual category that I had not yet had occasion to master, but also for its curated bibliography and suggestions for further reading. Overall, this is a brilliantly designed and executed book that addresses a real need in the field of Biblical Hebrew studies and pedagogy.

Kerry Lee
Fuller Theological Seminary
kerry.d.lee.jr [at] gmail.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: